In this post which was originally published on 3rd January 2021, Woking Labour welcome a submission from a local member who has written about their experience in teaching and the impact on schools over the Covid crisis:
Thoughts from the Front-Line of Schools
From ‘Another Whinging Teacher’
I am a teacher in a secondary school and I’ve been invited to write about my experiences since the COVID outbreak. Before I continue, I want to lay my cards on the table. I -like many others- believe this pandemic has been very poorly handled. I also feel strongly that schools have been central to this. Teaching & learning face-to-face is infinitely more effective than through a screen. However, there is much evidence now of a link between school attendance and rising COVID cases. This will have led to more deaths. I don’t think this was a price worth paying and I still don’t. Witnessing it all at close quarters has been incredibly disturbing.
One of the reasons for this is due -in part- to the way the pandemic has been mishandled by the Conservative government. We are now all familiar with the U-turns and poor messaging that Johnson, Hancock, Williamson and all have been responsible for. This has led to understandable confusion and misunderstanding in the public. There have been many common misconceptions related to the treatment of schools.
Common misconception #1:
One is that the government has been concerned about the mental health and general wellbeing of students. They have cited this as one of the main reasons to oppose the idea of teaching moving online. In reality, support for mental health, for general wellbeing and support for students with SEND (Special Educational Needs and Disabilities), has been cut to the bone after years of austerity. Child poverty rates -clearly associated with wellbeing- were also rising long before COVID. The Conservatives didn’t appear to care much about these things before COVID. Our profession finds it insulting that they’re claiming to care now.
Something about my experience over the last 10 months: I am lucky to teach in a modern building with good ventilation and opportunities to keep students apart. The students have been brilliant in adapting to the new regime (‘bubbled’ areas, hand-sanitiser at the doorway of each lesson, masks in the corridors etc), but in important ways, they have continued as if things were completely normal. As has frequently been said- it’s impossible to keep teenagers apart. They hug, high-five, gather together, share food etc. etc. Policing this would have been impossible -hence the ‘bubbles’ strategy. So, the virus came to our school and saw several whole year-group ‘bubbles’ sent home during the Autumn term. Staff have been mixed in their response to the situation. Some are terrified; having vulnerable loved ones at home, or worried about the impossibility of working at a distance to students (the situation has been particularly tough for TA’s who have to work 1 to 1 with students). Other have found it easy to forget the distancing principles. One reason may be because our teachers have to run the length of the school to teach heavier timetables. It’s harder to keep disciplined about not being closer to students than 1 metre for 1 minute at all times, when you’re carrying a set of books and are late for your boisterous Year 8 class and their previous teacher hasn’t requested a replacement bottle of sanitiser… Meanwhile we have had parents send children to school with symptoms. Were they merely taking a risk? Ignoring the rules? COVID deniers? Our community reflects society as a whole, so there will always be a diverse range of behaviours. So, teaching has been quite stressful. Staff have resigned over fear of infection.
During the first lockdown there was a different type of stress. I felt the same sense of powerless as many but was keen to help in any way I could. My team and I spent the first few weeks of the outbreak creating PPE visors to take to care homes. However, despite being hard-working, socially motivated, dedicated professionals, sections of the media continue to represent us as work-shy and negative.
Common misconception #2:
Schools -and I want to really emphasise this- were never closed. Vulnerable students and children of keyworkers were in school from the start. Online teaching was developed from scratch and with minimal, late support from government. We have worked extremely hard to fill gaps. Such remote teaching is not an easy option for teachers and requires its own skillset and planning. Many teachers I know are also parents of young children and dread blending work and home schooling their own children as much as many other parents do. In my twenty years of teaching, I have always been amazed at how low some people’s estimations are of teachers. The idea that teachers want schools to close, leaves me feeling extremely low.
How else do I feel now? Right now, I’m afraid. I don’t want to be associated with an experiment in unnecessary virus spreading and virus mutation that could lead to more infection and death. Going into school during this pandemic has gone against my core teacher instincts. My career choice was motivated by a duty of care for individuals and for my wider community. I also have a passion for encouraging students to think for themselves. This should be applied to life-long learners (all of us). Given the gaslighting and outright lies we have seen from this Conservative government, we need to be wary of the latest plan for schools to now become centres for COVID testing. The idea that we will now successfully carry out what the government have failed to do is yet another insult. At time of writing, the plan is to use this as a way of keeping students in school instead of isolating any suspected asymptomatic cases. Lateral Flow Tests have 50% accuracy in picking up such cases. Unless we are testing students very frequently, there is a real risk we will be seeing more of the disease in the student population – and into the wider community. We still don’t know how the mutant strain will affect possible infection rates. However …the public has been reassured that the army will be at hand to help out.
Latest Common Misconception #3:
1500 army personnel are due to be deployed to help thousands of secondary schools. The implication is that this will be hands-on support, but the reality is that there will be some ZOOM training. My guess is that this will not be the final insult. I am looking forward to spending the coming year continuing to navigate such last-minute ill-thought-through, car-crash guidance.
However, despite lots of fence-sitting from Starmer, I need to believe that a Labour government would do a better job. I want to resist the return to ‘they’re all as bad as each other’ apathy. We desperately need an alternative and I’m planning to do all I can to ensure this happens as soon as possible.
Anon (another whinging teacher)